Most Shared





text size

Howard Ain, Troubleshooter: Oil Pumping Scheme

Updated: Friday, January 30 2015, 09:32 AM EST
CINCINNATI (Howard Ain) -- Could you ever imagine hundreds of investors would get scammed by con artists?

Well in this case the Kentucky con-men knew exactly how to outsmart their victim.

Gary Milby pitched his company, Mid-America Oil and Gas, to potential investors.

"We guarantee production. These wells that I'm offering you folks today are going to last longer than I m going to live."

Milby provided a detailed prospectus, as well as what seemed like a strong argument on why investors should trust him.

"How many of those wells have productive? All of them? You re batting 100%? That's great. Yes sir. That sounds phenomenal in the oil business."

The man asking Milby questions is Robert Buechner, a lawyer, who had invested in similar projects with other companies.

"He basically guaranteed the wells would be productive and investors would make money."

Buechner was intrigued and did his due diligence including visiting the the oil wells to see them first-hand.  Buechner witnessed oil gushing out of the wells and was impressed.

"He would say, 'Oh my gosh this is going to be 60 barrels a day, this looks like a real winner, 90 barrels a day.'"

The truth: it was all a show.

"What we find is that they pumped that oil in and staged it for the investors to make an impression on them.  Postal inspectors say the presentations and the demonstration at the oil wells were all part of a scam.  It's another tactic they used to try and make people make a decision quickly and it plays on the investors emotions.

Gary Milby, along with attorney Brian Coffman, lured more than 260 victims into his scam.  Total losses were more than $36 million.

"Brian Coffman was the wizard in the Wizard of Oz movie; you pull back the curtain he was the one always pulling the strings."

Inspectors found Kaufman was depositing investors funds into accounts he and his family controlled.  The money bought condos and luxury items.

"He bought a yacht that was named For Your Eyes Only.  This yacht was purchased with investors funds and valued at 1.5 million dollars."

The scam began to unravel when investors starting asking questions about their statements.

"The big problem was we were not getting the money we were promised."

Buechner says he did everything he could to research the investment.  The problem was the con-artists in this case outsmarted the victims.

"This isn't a case of inadequate due diligence done, the due diligence was flawed, because you didn't get the right answers. I don't know how you get right answers, when you ask the right questions when people purposely give you the wrong answers."

Bryan Coffman and Gary Milby were both charged with 8 counts of mail fraud and 9 counts of wire fraud.  Milby was sentenced to 20 years in prison and Brian Coffman received 25.

VIDEO HEREHoward Ain, Troubleshooter: Oil Pumping Scheme

Advertise with us!

Related Stories

Scam Alert

  • E-greeting Card Scam

    The e-greeting card scam is not a new one, but the FBI says it's returned with a vengeance.

    It's Internet Crime Complaint Center is receiving an increasing number of complaints.

    The fraud e-cards contain malware as an attachment, or it contains a link which sends the recipient to a web page where they can pick up viruses, keystroke loggers or other so-called trojan horse programs.

    The e-cards sometimes even appear to be from legitimate e-card greeting web sites-- but the actual address of the links point to a numeric address, rather than one containing the name of the postcard company.

    If you get one of these e-mails you can file a complaint on the FBI's web site,
  • Jury Duty Scam

    Officials all across the Tri-State are warning about a jury duty scam that may put you at risk for identity theft.

    Police say someone has been calling residents and saying they face arrest for failing to report for jury duty.

    The caller asks people for personal information including their Social Security numbers to clear up the situation.

    Authorities say the calls are part of a nationwide scam. If you think you have been a victim call your local police or sheriff's department.

TroubleShooter Feedback

Do you have a problem that needs Howard's attention? Fill out the form below and let him know!
Please re-enter the code shown in the image below.
Advertise with us!