- Wind Could Ground Macy's Parade Balloons
- O.J. Simpson Denied a New Trial
- Florida GOP Leaders Call for Radel to Resign
- Conn. Couple Celebrate 81st Wedding Anniversary
- Mother of Bullied Fla. Girl Wants Tougher Laws
- Ford to Recall Escapes Again for Oil, Fuel Leaks
- Nationwide Goal for 2024 Moving toward No-Kill Animal Shelters
- Murder Charges Filed After Building Collapse
- Yale on Lockdown as Gun Report Investigated
- Police: NY deli owners stole $1M lottery ticket
- Deal Reached in Iranâs Nuclear Program
- Video game re-enacts Sandy Hook shooting, relatives outraged
- High amount of workers to seek new jobs in 2014
- Senate Vote to Honor Doolittle Raiders
- Two Deaths Prompt Baby Monitor Recall
- Kennedy Cousin Granted Bail as He Awaits New Trial
- Navy Sailor And Fiancee Married At Reno-Tahoe International Airport
- At McDonald's, a push for customization
- Jumbo Jet Stuck at Small Airport
- Execution of Serial Killer Brings Peace to Local Family
- Florida Congressman Pleads Guilty After Cocaine Arrest
- President's Approval Rate Lowest of his Presidency
- Adam Levine named People's 'sexiest man alive'
- Study: Kids are less fit than their parents were
- Gas Prices Predicted to Stay Down
- Congressman and Cincinnati Native Busted on Drug Charges
- Judge Sets George Zimmerman's Bond at $9,000
- Virginia State Senator Stabbed, Son is Killed
- New Poll: 86% Of Working Americans Plan To Online Shop During Work Hours On Cyber Monday
- George Zimmerman Arrested After Disturbance Call
- 8 People Confirmed Dead from Tornadoes
- Missouri Governor Denies Killer Clemency
- In traffic stop chaos, NM officer fires at van
- Ohio Walmart Holds Food Drive for Its Own Employees
- US Postal Service Reports 7th Year of Net Loss
- 'Batkid' Begins Fighting Crime In San Francisco
- Digital pickpockets using smartphones to steal credit cards
- Florida Sinkhole Destroys Two Homes
- Mother Questions School Grading System
- Google patenting an electronic 'throat tattoo'
- Suspect Shot Inside Children's Hospital in Wisconsin
- Policy Cancellations: Obama Will Allow Old Plans
- Mob Boss Whitey Bulger Sentenced to Life in Prison
- Sex and Booze; Colorado 'Obamacare' Ads Raising Eyebrows
- NJ man, ex-girlfriend in court over Powerball win
- Sinkhole Swallows Florida Man's Backyard
- 16-Year-Old Charged for Shooting Near School
- Immigration Reform: House Will Not Talk on Senate-Passed Bill
- Shooting Reported Near Pittsburgh High School
- 'Star Wars: Episode VII' holding open casting call
- Student sues Montana college after flunking math
- Texas Teacher Punches, Knocks Out Student
- Male vs Female Bosses
- SeaWorld challenges ban limiting interaction between whale and trainer
- McConnell promotes alternative to 'Obamacare'
- Experts Settle Dispute Over America's Tallest Building
- California town builds house for wounded GI
- Cost of Thanksgiving Dinner Rises
- PG-13 Gun Violence Rivals that of R Movies
- Why A Midweek Wedding? Because It's 11/12/13
- College students could face expulsion for using gun to fend off intruder
- Suit: NY dad criticized for denying son McDonald's
- Amazon and USPS Partner for Sunday Delivery
- Target Will Open Earlier on Thanksgiving Than Last Year
- What would Jesus brew? Churches turn to serving beer to attract members
- US adds 204,000 jobs, jobless rate up to 7.3 pct.
- Gay Rights Bill to Outlaw Workplace Discrimination
- Suicide Bombings Kill 19 at Iraq Military Base
- Bank ATM spits out $50 bills instead of $20 bills
- Critics: Some Unions Could Get Break From Fees
- Price of average CVG flight second-most expensive
- High court wrestles with prayer in government
- Russian fireball shows meteor risk may be bigger
- Blockbuster closing all of its retail stores
- Castro Victim Talks About 11 Years in Captivity
- Lay's New Chocolate-Covered Potato Chips
- Toys R Us To Open At 5 p.m. On Thanksgiving Day
- Northwestern unveils Wounded Warrior uniforms
- Police: Teens Broke into Denver School to Steal
- Suspect in NJ Mall Shooting Found Dead
- Johnson & Johnson Resolves Criminal and Civil Allegations
- Lock Down Lifted at CCSU
- 3 people in police custody after lock down at Central Connecticut State U
- Feds Urge Students to Check Loan Repayment Plans
- November means facial hair
- Obamacare: Memo reveals health care adviser warned W.H. was losing control 3 years ago
- Alligator captured in Chicago's O'Hare Airport
- Texans Coach in Stable Condition After Last Night's Collapse
- Witness to LAX Shooting Speaks Out
- Judge dresses as fairy godmother during adoption ceremony
- 14-Pound Utah Baby May Be America's Biggest For 2013
- McDonald's to sell bagged coffee next year
- Suspect in Custody in LAX Shooting
- Appeals Court Rules Against Obamacare over Contraceptives
- Report: Obama campaign considered replacing Biden with Hillary Clinton
- Drug Tunnel Uncovered
- Hot-Sauce Lawsuit Rejected
- Study examines the best time for a coffee break
- Holiday travel: Procrastinators will pay this year, expert says
- Spying Scandal: Break Ins at Yahoo and Google Data Centers
- Italian Magazine Alleges NSA Spying on Cardinals
- President Obama Defends Health Care Law
- Report: NSA Broke into Yahoo, Google Data Centers
- N.D. woman to hand out
- Sebelius Apologizes for Health Care Website
- Social Security Increase Released
- Soldier in Spiderman suit surprises daughter
- Penn State to Pay Nearly $60 Million over Sandusky Claims
- Report: White House stopped phone tapping of foreign leaders this summer
- Conrad Murray Released From Jail
- Sandy Hook Elementary Torn Down
- Demolition of Sandy Hook Elementary Begins
- Indictments of JonBenet Ramsey's Parents Released
- Gunman Who Held People Hostage in Drugstore Surrenders
- Two Shot at Naval Base in Tennessee
- Virginia woman to launch ad campaign... to find a husband
- Community Stunned by Killing of Young Teacher
- National Security Official Fired over Twitter Account
- White House Denies Spying on German Chancellor
- Repairs, scaffolding ahead for US Capitol dome
- Merkel calls Obama to complain about surveillance
- Texas dad alleges bullying in 91-0 football game
- Homicide Investigation Closes Massachusetts School District
- Warning to Pet Owners about Jerky Treats After Deaths Reported
- U.S. Drone Strikes May Constitute War Crimes
- Concealed Gun Carrier Stops Man Threatening Party with Rifle
- Three Killed in Medical Helicopter Crash in Tennessee
- Three sisters hold last-minute joint wedding so their dying mother can attend
- Father charged after 2-year-old fatally shoots herself
- 'Hero' Math Teacher Credited With Saving Lives in Sparks School Shooting
- Harley-Davidson issues voluntary recall of certain '14 motorcycles over hydraulic clutch issue
- 15 Yr-Old Davion Navar Henry Only Pleads For Family To Adopt Him At Church
- Curtis W. Croft Busted When Cops Use Google Earth To Find Pot Garden
- Republican Approval Rates Take a Hit after Shutdown
- Builders of Obama's Health Care Website Saw Red Flags
- Facebook Outage Blamed on 'Network Maintenance'
- Police: Teens beat Pa. man, 65, over parking space
- Boy Scouts remove 2 men who toppled ancient rock
- Holmes defense, prosecutors resume evidence battle
- Detroit man charged in rape, murder of girl, 5
- 'Joker' charged with driving drunk in Maine
- Obama addresses widespread health care problems
- 1 dead in triple shooting at Vegas Strip nightclub
- AP sources: 476,000 Obamacare applications filed
- Raymond becomes major hurricane as it nears Mexico
- Man pleads guilty to shooting golfer who hit home
- Feds to listen to audio in SF Bay Area rail deaths
- Escaped Fla. prisoners grilled: Who helped you?
- Study: 15 percent of US youth out of school, work
- Gay Marriage to be Allowed in New Jersey
- No Charges for Firefighter in Survivor's Death
- Ex-House speaker Tom Foley dies at 84
- New York man arrested in terrorism case
- Halloween Decor Prompts 911 Calls
- Toilet-themed restaurant set to open in California
- Wal-Mart staffer Kristopher Oswald says he was fired for trying to save woman in parking lot assault
- Big asteroid buzzes past Earth and will again in 19 years
- Man Loses Weight With Beer and Sausage Diet
- Teen found with fetus in bag at store, NYPD says
- New GPS System Can Track School Bus for Parents
- Federal Workers Back in Business
- President Urges Cooperation as Federal Workers Return to Jobs
- 'Deadliest substance known to man' discovered
- New Facebook Policy Lets Teens Share More
- Jilted bride turns wedding into party for people with disabilities
- House Worker Escorted Out After Yelling During Vote
- White House: Furloughed Workers Can Return to Work
- Government Shutdown Over
- 18-foot-long sea creature found off Calif. coast
- Senator: Deal to avoid default and open government
- Furloughed Workers Can Send Creditors a Note from Government
- GOP senator says deal in hand to avoid default
- 4 dead after boat capsizes off Florida coast
- Today is Nat'l Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Day
- Optimism on Ending Gov. Shutdown?
- No Deal in Government Shutdown
- Starving Dog Found Chained to a Tree
- 9 Year Old Sneaks Onto a Plane
- 6th Grade Boys Cause Hump Day Ban
- Locals Affected by Government Shutdown
High court wrestles with prayer in government
Updated: Wednesday, November 6 2013, 03:16 PM EST
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The Supreme Court wrestled Wednesday with the appropriate role for religion in government in a case involving mainly Christian prayers at the start of a New York town's council meetings.
The justices began their day with the marshal's customary plea that "God save the United States and this honorable court." They then plunged into a lively give-and-take that highlighted the sensitive nature of offering religious invocations in public proceedings that don't appeal to everyone and governments' efforts to police the practice.
The court is weighing a federal appeals court ruling that said the Rochester suburb of Greece, N.Y., violated the Constitution because nearly every prayer in an 11-year span was overtly Christian.
The tenor of the argument indicated the justices would not agree with the appellate ruling. But it was not clear what decision they might come to instead.
Justice Elena Kagan summed up the difficult task before the court when she noted that "every time the court gets involved in things like this, it seems to make the problem worse rather than better."
The justices tried out several approaches to the issue, including one suggested by the two Greece residents who sued over the prayers to eliminate explicit references to any religion.
Justice Samuel Alito pointed to the country's religious diversity to voice his skepticism about the call for only nonsectarian prayer. "I just don't see how it is possible to compose anything that you could call a prayer that is acceptable to all of these groups," Alito said.
As Douglas Laycock, the University of Virginia law professor representing the residents, tried to craft an answer, Justice Antonin Scalia and Chief Justice John Roberts jumped in. "You want to pick the groups we're going to exclude?" Scalia said. A few seconds later, Roberts chimed in, "We've already excluded the atheists, right?"
Greece is being backed by the Obama administration and many social and religious conservative groups in arguing that the court settled this issue 30 years ago when it held that an opening prayer is part of the nation's fabric and not a violation of the First Amendment. Some of those groups want the court to go further and get rid of legal rules that tend to rein in religious expression in the public sphere, though there was little talk of that on Wednesday.
On the other side are Greece residents Susan Galloway and Linda Stephens who contend they and others who attend the meetings are a captive audience and should not be subjected to sectarian prayers.
Their argument appealed to Justice Sonia Sotomayor who asked Deputy Solicitor General Ian Gershengorn what he and others in the courtroom would do if Roberts "got up at the beginning of this session and said, `All rise for a prayer."
Gershengorn said, "I don't think many would sit, Your Honor."
People attending meetings in Greece wouldn't feel any differently, Sotomayor said. "So why do you think that someone who is sitting in a small room where hearings of this nature are being held, when the guy who's about, the chairman of this legislative body, is about to rule on an application you're bringing to him or her, why do you think any of those people wouldn't feel coerced to stand?" she said.
The case is the first on prayer at government meetings since Marsh v. Chambers, the 1983 case that said prayer in the Nebraska Legislature did not violate the First Amendment's clause barring laws "respecting an establishment of religion," known as the Establishment Clause.
The potentially decisive vote in the case belongs to Justice Anthony Kennedy, who did not seem satisfied with arguments made by lawyers for Greece and the administration on one side and for the town's residents on the other.
On the one hand, Kennedy said he did not like the thought that government officials or judges would examine the content of the prayers to make sure they are not sectarian. "That involves the State very heavily in the censorship and the approval or disapproval of prayers," Kennedy said.
On the other hand, he objected to the reliance by the town and the administration on the decision in the 1983 Marsh case.
All the while, Justice Stephen Breyer was trying out potential outcomes that recognized both the tradition of prayer and the rights of religious minorities and nonbelievers. "If all that was left in the case were questions of making a good-faith effort to include others, would you object to doing it?" Breyer asked Thomas Hungar, the Washington, D.C., lawyer who is representing the town.
Hungar said he did not know but asserted that the town already has engaged in the outreach Breyer described.
Later, Breyer asked Laycock if he would be satisfied with an outcome in which the town maintained its prayer practice, but routinely advised ministers in advance of offering a prayer that the audience "is comprised of members of many different faith traditions."
Laycock replied, "That would help immensely."
In Greece, every meeting was opened with a Christian-oriented invocation from 1999 through 2007, and again from January 2009 through June 2010. In 2008, after Galloway and Stephens complained, four of 12 meetings were opened by non-Christians, including a Jewish layman, a Wiccan priestess and the chairman of the local Baha'i congregation.
Hungar said the town's website shows four other instances in which the person who gave the prayer was not Christian, once each in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2013.
The two residents lost their suit in U.S. District Court after the judge found that the town did not intentionally exclude non-Christians and that the content of the prayer was not an issue because there was no desire to proselytize or demean other faiths.
But a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said that even with the high court's 1983 ruling, the practice of having one Christian prayer after another amounted to the town's endorsement of Christianity.
A decision is expected by late June.
The case is Greece v. Galloway, 12-696.
© 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.